On 3 Oct 2002, Derek Neighbors wrote:
> > True, if I can track back the entire chain of contributors to a GPLed
> > commodity then I can contract for each to supply his or her own contribution
> > on commercial terms.
> > But in many cases this is not practical. GPL is designed so that over time
> > getting a clear commercially viable contract for any significant GPL product
> > becomes virtually impossible thanks to the tangled web of contributions and
> > dependencies.
>
> Poor copyright management is problematic regardless of licensing.
Thank you Derek - this is the one piece of Trent's
rhetoric that I couldn't solve. Seems obvious now
that you say that.
If a piece of software is comprised of, say, ten
components, and each component must be licensed
individually, it is less practical than the same
software with a single license holder. It has
nothing to do with what type of license it is.
Suppose, for example, that someone writes a spreadsheet
(A) for doing commodity options pricing. Someone
else adds a dependant spreadsheet (B) that specifies
spreadsheet A for metals. A third person writes a
spreadsheet (C) that specifies B for precious metals.
A fourth person writes a spreadsheet (D) that specifies
C for platinum. You have an end product that is just
as hard to license for commercial resale regardless of
whether each component spreadsheet is licensed under
a "no resale" license which must be negotiated
independently or a "no proprietization" license which
must be negotiated independently.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"We're on the threshold of a whole new system. The time where
accountants decide what music people hear is coming to an
end. Accountants may be good at numbers, but they have terrible taste
in music. I don't know how I'm going to get paid, but I'd rather go
out into the brave new world than live with dinosaurs that are far too
big for their boots." - Keith Richards - Rolling Stones Guitarist
----------------------------------------------------------------------
(text/plain)