Re: request you top post please

Top Page
Attachments:
Message as email
+ (text/plain)
+ (text/html)
+ (text/plain)
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Author: mike@mjv.com
Date:  
To: Main PLUG discussion list
Subject: Re: request you top post please




Not everyone? Let's say MOST. I've been on 70+ listservs for over a decade
and bottom-posters are extremely rare at best. If everyone else is posting
a certain way consistently, why suddenly say they're wrong and demand
posting the opposite way? I mean, what is right and wrong with the
difference between top and bottom posting as if one is evil and the other
good? In this case, majority rules. Trying to make people do something
different on one list than on all the other lists is just ridiculous and
disingenuous.

Be well,
Mike in Zone 8, Texas
--
http://www.taroandti.com/ Exotic Plant Info and More...
http://www.organichomesteading.com/ Organic Homesteading
http://www.naturalbeefarm.com/ Mike's Bee Farm


On Fri,
August 13, 2010 12:42 pm, Joseph Sinclair wrote:
> Ed,
>

Not everyone agrees with the bottom-post-for-technical approach, it's a
> personal preference more than anything. Technomage_Hawke is using

reading
> tools that don't skip effectively (no visual interface).

It's not a lack
> of GUI, it's a lack of any capability to see the

text, and he's
> absolutely correct that viewing bottom-post in a

screen reader or braille
> reader is excruciating, at best.
>
> If you must bottom post, then you should trim out all

the history you
> refer to below (just as I did to your split

posting below) as a simple
> courtesy to people who can't actually

use their eyes to skim over it.
>
> I've generally found

the following compromise to work reasonably well:
>
>
> 1) top post if it makes sense to do so, if people want the history

they
> can keep reading. 2) post interlocutory if you're

responding
> point-by-point to something; bracket your comments

with --- so the
> visually impaired can tell more easily when the

author changes. 3) Bottom
> post if it's preferred on a list or if

someone requests it, but remove as
> much of the thread history as

you can so screen readers and braille
> devices don't have to

re-read the entire conversation with every email. 4)
> Use a

thread-aware email client to make it easier to accept that others
> should make their own choices in this regard.
>
>

Just my thoughts,
> ==Joseph++



---------------------------------------------------
PLUG-discuss mailing list -
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings:
http://lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss