Sccts guy contradicts RIAA document

[Chris Gehlker]

On Jan 6, 2008, at 7:35 PM, Craig White wrote:

> The story wasn't what was in the pleadings, regardless of what Fisher
> said. He got the story right but he is not, nor will he ever be an
> intellectual property expert.

No, he did not 'get the story right'. He said he was reporting on the  
pleadings and then he misrepresented what the pleadings said. They are  
fairly straightforward but if he really didn't understand them, then  
he had an obligation not to file his report.

I don't believe he misunderstood the pleadings. He simply  
mischaracterized and sensationalized them.
>
>
> Plaintiff continually refuses to admit that defendant has any legal
> right to have mp3 versions of CD's on his computer for any reason.

*After* Fisher's story was published the plaintiff's spokesman  
wouldn't confirm that his client recognized the right to have personal  
copies. That can't conceivably make Fisher's story accurate. If I post  
a story to this list saying that Craig White died yesterday it is  
hardly an accurate story simply because you are not immortal.

--
Seven Deadly Sins? I thought it was a to-do list!