Advice
keith@christianexchange.org
keith@christianexchange.org
Thu, 22 Mar 2001 13:09:53 -0700
One of the potential problems from asking too many questions is they will
look at you as a problem child.
I try to explain that I need enough information to make a good decision
because I would like to stay for a while. (I am not adverse to leaving a
place soon after starting if it does not meet my needs, and of course my
employer *_will_* discharge me if I do not meet their needs.)
I find the best way to find out about a company is to find an employee that
will give you the real insight. I find this the best approach.
Of course this only my 2 cents
In Peace,
Keith Smith
----- Original Message -----
From: Kimi A. Adams <kimi@unitywave.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2001 9:42:11 AM
To: <plug-discuss@lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us>
Subject: Re: Advice
> Well said. I haven't been following all replies to this posting because
of
> a busy schedule, but I know this to be true. I worked temporary jobs on
> and off for over ten years. When you work with this kind of hostile
> atmosphere as well as having to sometimes interview for even a short term
> position, you learn quickly that if you don't ask the right questions,
you
> will be stuck in a short term job that is stressing you out. Then you
have
> to jump right into the next one because there may not be another for a
week
> or even several.
>
> When interviewing with someone, I always ask why the position is being
> filled. What happened to the previous person. If that person is
pregnant
> or very seriously ill, then I know it's not for internal issues or
> something that would complicate my life. If they dance around the
> question, then I point blank tell them that if they had a problem, such
as
> personality conflicts, that I would have to consider whether it was with
a
> current employee or the person leaving. That's leaves you open for more
> details, possibly more than you want, but at least you would know.
>
> It's rare to find other people that teach interviewing skills that
includes
> you, the prospective employee, asking very pertinent questions to them,
the
> employer. If you try to save your butt in any other situation, then why
is
> it that you don't when you interview? I mean, it's the place that you
will
> spend most of your weekday hours, all week at and if you don't like it or
> it makes your life off from work too stressful, then why bother.
>
> But on the other hand, if I don't receive 100% commitment from the people
> that I hire, they are going to be relieved from duty. Compensate the
hard
> working employees, give them lunch everyday, give them a flexible
schedule,
> give them enough time off and flexibility to do their work and deal with
> personal issues. That's what I do with my people. It's their choice to
> work or not, but mine to relieve them of duty if they don't cut
> it. Dedication is imperative for any company so treating them as if they
> are robots, trained to only do instead of think is the mentality of
> Corporate America. Small businesses rein in that area because I cannot
use
> a robot, I need an Einstein or something at least with the brains to
figure
> out that creativity will get you everywhere you want to go.
>
> Kimi
>
>
>
> At 3/22/01 08:57 AM, you wrote:
>
> >----- Original Message -----
> >From: George Toft <george@georgetoft.com>
> >To: <plug-discuss@lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us>
> >Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2001 10:15 PM
> >Subject: Re: Advice
> >
> >
> > > That's what I did at my last job. My 30 seconds were focused on:
> > > How long at each job.
> > > Did he/she put the skills I asked for on the resume.
> > > Education.
> > >
> > > I had one resume that actually said Linux as a skill, as this was a
> > > Linux position (98% of the resumes had MS all over it). I asked
> > > him if he knew anything about Linux. He said "What do you mean?"
> > > I replied: "Do you know more than just how to spell it?" He responded
> > > by pressing one of the buttons on the phone keypad, and hung up on
> > > me. My reaction: Filing the resume in the "No Way" pile.
> > >
> > > We each have our ways of filtering candidates (or employers).
> > >
> > > George
> > >
> >
> >
> >George please don't take this as a personal attack. I think we can all
> >learn a lot from each other. You think interviewing as a hiring manager
is
> >tough, so is interviewing for a prospective position. There are the
sweat
> >shops, the cheapies, the no benefits, full-time or part-time jobs
> >masquerading as an internship........ ETC.
> >
> >Phone interviews are tough. No body language. Maybe he thought you were
> >being rude or making fun of him. Without actually being there, and not
> >knowing you, my assessment of your question "Do you know more than just
how
> >to spell it?" would turn me off and I would probably end the interview
soon
> >after.
> >
> >I recently got a call from a company that wanted to know if I was
interested
> >in working for them. After I said yes they asked how much I wanted. I
> >asked for a mid-range salary given my skill set and experience. The guy
> >wanted to pay $7,000 less (entry level) and quit talking with me. He
said
> >he was using a headhunter and needed to continue along that path. This
> >makes no since to me because I know he will pay about $12,000 to find
> >someone who will stay no more than 2 years once they find out how much
they
> >can really make. The math works out that I only wanted about $1000 more
a
> >year by not going through a headhunter. Entry level and save $1000 a
year
> >VS. years of experience with the exact tools - Go Figure!
> >
> >One of the things I find interesting is the "What do you want?" question.
> >When I interviewed with a small mom and pop software company several
years
> >ago this is how I responded: "More money is not all that important to
me, I
> >would like more vacation time." I went on to tell them I would like 4 or
> >more weeks of vacation in stead of a pay raise. I actually told them I
> >would be willing to take less money if I received more time off than I
was
> >getting from my employer at the time. They treated me like I was some
sort
> >of freak!
> >
> >Several years ago I received a call from a Phoenix company (I live in
> >Tucson) and was told they wanted to interview me. I asked for a phone
> >interview to determine if driving to Phoenix would be a good use of my
time.
> >I explained that during most interviews within 5 minutes I know I do not
> >want to work for them or they know they do not want me, and I would hate
to
> >drive 2 hours to Phoenix and 2 hours back to spend 5 minutes finding out
it
> >would not be worth while to continue the process. I never receive a
follow
> >up call. This tells me this company does not care about their employees
of
> >which I will never be.
> >
> >I have a ton of personal stories. I've accepted offers which ended up
being
> >something different than what was presented and I ended up quitting soon
> >after. It was my intent to stay a while, maybe even a little longer,
when I
> >accepted the position. One of things to ponder when hiring someone is
they
> >may be processing with several companies. If you hire them under false
> >pretence they will know. They may be getting offers within weeks or
months
> >of accepting a position with your company. After several weeks they
know if
> >they were sold a bill of goods. This happened with my wife. She
applied at
> >several places, having her hopes on one company. She received an offer
> >within days and took the job. The place had top notch pay and benefits
> >however the work environment was very hostile. Several month later after
> >having her fill of harassment and hostility she was offered a position
with
> >the original company she wanted to work for. It meant several dollars an
> >hour pay reduction and a lesser benefit package. She looked that this
> >prospect long and hard to make sure she was not jumping from the frying
pan
> >into the fire. She took the job with less pay and benefits and likes it
> >much more.
> >
> >So hiring managers beware, we are sizing you up too.
> >
> >Interviewing is tough and no fun. I've become very aggressive in
> >interviewing my prospective employer. I'm tired of finding out that what
> >the job and work place are really like is nothing like what they
presented.
> >I'm sure candidates lie and embellish. I know managers do.
> >
> >With 401k and portable health insurance moving from one job to the next
is
> >very easy. I think most people change jobs every 2 or 3 years.
> >
> >I find most leads and managers think they need to beat their subordinates
> >with a stick to get results. Employees are like dogs. Beat them with a
> >stick and they bite you! Show them a little love, compassion,
> >understanding, through them a treat, buy them lunch, give them a day off,
> >and they will follow you all over the place - loyalty will be second to
> >none. They will even follow you to your next company. You will hear
rumors
> >of wars and later find your loyal servant had fought the battle
protecting
> >you without ever involving you. Shall I go on? Be an average employer
and
> >see how fast people avoid responsibility and how poorly your group will
> >perform. You will train a new employee to loose them...... People tend
to
> >rise to your expectation of them. Employees are like dogs!
> >
> >This was not meant as a personal attack.
> >
> >With love, peace, and respect,
> >Keith Smith
> >
> >
> ><SNIP>
> >
> >
> >
> >________________________________________________
> >See http://PLUG.phoenix.az.us/navigator-mail.shtml if your mail doesn't
> >post to the list quickly and you use Netscape to write mail.
> >
> >Plug-discuss mailing list - Plug-discuss@lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us
> >http://lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss
>
>
> ________________________________________________
> See http://PLUG.phoenix.az.us/navigator-mail.shtml if your mail doesn't
post to the list quickly and you use Netscape to write mail.
>
> Plug-discuss mailing list - Plug-discuss@lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us
> http://lists.PLUG.phoenix.az.us/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss