I've used ssd's as boot drives since the first 32gb units from random vendors, and most have been terrible lasting 6mo-1yr generally before death.  Past 4-5 years, using Samsungs or Toshiba (oddly), I've had good luck.

SSD's need some wear-leveling involved in hardware, or they die.  My experience at least, but I have had several die across raid pairs, one always just flatlines suddenly.

I use encryption, raid, and lvm in fs setup, so it is simply required as ssd trim is generally not working as a pass through function without security issues.  If you can't do direct trim support, or wear-leveling is involved at a hardware leveling, mine have died, at least one at a time.  This is at least 3 different vendors, including corsair, adata, and another I already forgot.

Since moving to Samsung SSD's I've not lost one.  I use Pro's in my desktop and my last laptop in raid, plus several evo's in some test systems that I use for network test rigs.  All have outlasted _any_ other SSD I have owned.  They cost more, but they haven't died like, oh every other one.

My xps15 came with a toshiba 1tb that I don't know if uses active wear-leveling, but it's been good to me.  I use it in place of my desktop mostly now for almost 3yr, and it's been solid, but non-redundant.  My last laptop took at least redundant mssd's with a pair of samsung 950 pro's that was great, but my current xps15 has one m2 sadly.

I use some other random ssd's still from failed raid pairs as odd drives (if it dies, f-it) still, it just seems random what works.  I generally didn't even reformat leaving them md raid drives, and they work, but in a pair once _always_ died, till the Samsungs.

-mb


On Sun, Dec 1, 2019 at 1:13 PM William Lindley <wlindley@wlindley.com> wrote:

Contemplating ordering an SSD as at least the boot and main drive for my PC.

Is that even a good idea?  Are /var, logfiles, and all the other stuff that constantly gets written to disk, still a Really Bad Idea for solid-state memory with its limited write cycle times?

Or is that no longer an issue?

And does anyone really trust SSD to maintain actual documents, family photos, and such over long periods of time?

\\/

---------------------------------------------------
PLUG-discuss mailing list - PLUG-discuss@lists.phxlinux.org
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings:
https://lists.phxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss