Inline: On 10/19/2012 11:16 PM, der.hans wrote: > Am 19. Oct, 2012 schwätzte Joseph Sinclair so: > <> > MHL means one remote controls both TV and the plugin device? Do you have > to switch back in forth like TV/Sat/DVD/AUX or can you just change > channels or change volume and the correct thing happens? With the MHL connection, the device has no remote control of it's own, everything is controlled by the host device; that includes volume. > > Finally found a video showing a remote with a TV to control a phone over > MHL. > > http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SmuvzfkyP78 > > I don't see him changing volume, but I would think the TV could be kept at > constant volume and changing the phone volume would be sufficient. No, The phone volume has no effect as the output stream is a straight digital content stream. The TV controls volume. > > What about for the roku stick? Same, the TV does volume, the stick just provides an A/V data stream. > > What about integration with an OTA receiver? Can Roku handle that as a > channel? No, He would switch to (e.g.) HDMI-3 for the Roku, and HDMI-1 for the OTA. Most TV remotes can make this a single button for each source. > > I need simple. While the person is intelligent, whatever I set up might be > a brand new interface to learn multiple times a day on the bad days. Simple is good, and I have gotten some absolutely technophobic persons to use Roku just fine (as long as I turn on the system; I have a complex turn-on sequence due to having 5 non-integrated devices, something you'll want to avoid), and switching (via single-button) from Roku to OTA is not a problem when I provide a small instruction sheet (3 sentences [for Watch TV, Watch Movies, Turn Off], fits on a 3X5 in 16pt Courier). I should mention that some of the newer "Smart" TV sets have built-in streaming video capability (including viewing any DLNA content on the local net), and that can be made fairly simple to use as well with a bit of remote-control programming. > > ciao, > > der.hans <>