<frenchie@magusnet.gilbert.az.us> wrote:
> [...]
> See my complete firewall /etc/inetd.conf below:
> ======================================
> auth   stream  tcp     nowait.32768    nobody    /usr/sbin/in.identd
in.identd -l -e -o -i -n

Why run auth, or are there users on the firewall itself using IRC and such?
Wouldn't they be behind the firewall?

> cfinger stream tcp nowait root /usr/sbin/tcpd /bin/cat
/home/frenchie/Mail/info
> finger stream tcp nowait root /usr/sbin/tcpd /bin/cat
/home/frenchie/Mail/info

So what's in /home/frenchie/Mail/info? While cat is probably not a risk,
does it need to run as root?

> ssh stream  tcp nowait  root    /usr/sbin/tcpd /usr/local/sbin/sshd.new -i

This one, I get! :)

I'm just curious about these things. I've had a lot of fun with firewalls
over the last couple of years and am always looking for "new ways" to secure
my stuff.

One thing I had running for a bit was a DMZ config using port redirection
under Linux. I had a 3rd NIC specifically for DMZ traffic. Nothing
terminated on the firewall itself. All "inbound" services were redirected to
a DMZ box. I had the firewall set up so that only ESTABLISHED connections on
select services were allowed from the DMZ interface. No DMZ host could
initiate a connection. It could answer calls, but not make them.

Since this was controlled by the firewall machine, and it didn't answer a
thing itself, I considered it a good protection in the event a DMZ host were
compromised. They might get to it, but they couldn't get anywhere else from
there, nor harm others. The firewall was essentially invisible, not even
answering icmp queries. The internal interface was hidden via
masquerade(NAT) and also protected.

The only thing that made me scrap this was not being able to figure out how
to allow an internal machine to periodically poll the DMZ mail host. I had
internal users connecting straight to the DMZ mail host for reading mail
(IMAP). IMAP was restricted from the outside via the firewall, but even so,
I didn't want that exposure or user mailboxes in a potentially exposed area
for any length of time. I suppose I could've set the mailhost to accept SMTP
mail from the outside, but used UUCP to batch it to the internal mail host,
but my head pretty much exploded after trying to sort through the O'Reilly
Sendmail (Bat) book.

Of course, I had the benefit of not having to serve external users. This
sure makes security a hell of a lot easier. I sympathize with those working
in ISP scenarios!

I've attached my firewall init scrit below for anyone that's interested. Be
forewarned that it's not an example of excellent shell scripting, nor do the
'stop' and 'restart' portions work correctly in handling the masq modules.
It did work though, it just generated some ugly messags. For the curious,
the IPs shown are NO LONGER CORRECT for my system (thanks to @Home recently
upgrading my cable modem) so please do NOT poke at them! There are also
probably some broken parts as I was in the middle of working on it when I
wound up with a Cisco router to play with instead. I think I've fixed all
the obvious problems. It's also a RedHat environment, though it could easily
be modified for any other distribution.

Any feedback appreciated!

- Bob

#!/bin/sh
# *************************************************************
# Intialize a full-time Ethernet link to the Internet via cable
# modem. I'm doing all initialization of the ports, and default
# security here.
#
# The following diagram illustrates the pyhsical network:
#
#                      +---------+  192.168.100.0
#         24.1.193.48  |         |- eth0 - internal --
# -- external -- eth2 -| Gateway |
#                      |         |- eth1 - DMZ -------
#                      +---------+  192.168.10.0
#
# eth2 is our external interface at 24.1.193.48, providing
# a connection to the Cox@Home network via cable modem. This
# network is considered 'untrusted' for all purposes.
#
# eth1 is our 'Demilitarized Zone' (DMZ) network, providing
# a location for limited access from the outside world. This
# network is assigned the 192.168.10.0/24 subnet. This network
# is also considered 'untrusted', with the assumption
# that exposed resources will reside here. If they're com-
# promised, we will restrict what can be accessed from there.
# Note that a DMZ is probably overkill for the average home
# configuration.
#
# eth0 is our internal network, providing network access to
# individual desktop workstations. It is assigned the
# 192.168.100.0/24 network subnet, and is considered 'trusted'
# from the perspective of physical access.
# *************************************************************

PATH=/sbin:/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin

# *************************************************************
# Configuration Parameters
# *************************************************************

ANYWHERE="0.0.0.0/0"
UNPRIVPORTS="1024:65535"

# Initialize our EXTERNAL network settings.
# I'm using fixed addressing for now, but need
# to eventually work all this with DHCP.
EXTERN_IF="eth2"
EXTERN_IP="24.1.193.48"
EXTERN_NET="24.1.192.0"
EXTERN_MASK="255.255.248.0"
EXTERN_BCAST="24.1.199.255"
EXTERN_GW="24.1.192.1"

# Initialize our INTERNAL network settings.
# This is in "private" network space per RFC1918.
# We will use masquerade (N:1 NAT) for these stations.
INTERN_IF="eth1"
INTERN_IP="192.168.100.1"
INTERN_NET="192.168.100.0"
INTERN_MASK="255.255.255.0"
INTERN_BCAST="192.168.100.255"

# Initialize our DMZ network settings.
# This is in "private" network space per RFC1918.
# We will use masquerade (N:1 NAT) for these stations.
DMZ_IF="eth0"
DMZ_IP="192.168.10.2"
DMZ_NET="192.168.10.0"
DMZ_MASK="255.255.255.0"
DMZ_BCAST="192.168.10.255"

# Source function library.
. /etc/rc.d/init.d/functions

# Unload support modules for IP Masquerade (N:1 NAT)
unload_modules() {
        modprobe -r ip_masq_ftp
        modprobe -r ip_masq_irc
        modprobe -r ip_masq_raudio
        modprobe -r ip_masq_user
        modprobe -r ip_masq_vdolive
}

# Load support modules for IP Masquerade (N:1 NAT)
load_modules() {
        if [ -e /var/lock/subsys/firewall ]; then
            unload_modules
        fi
        modprobe ip_masq_ftp
        modprobe ip_masq_irc
        modprobe ip_masq_raudio
        modprobe ip_masq_user
        modprobe ip_masq_vdolive
}

# Delete firewall chains
clear_all_chains() {
        if [ -e /var/lock/subsys/firewall ]; then
            # ipmasqadm mfw -F
     ipmasqadm portfw -d -P tcp -L 24.1.193.48 80 -R 192.168.10.10 80
            ipchains -F int-in
            ipchains -X int-in
            ipchains -F int-out
            ipchains -X int-out
            ipchains -F int-fwd
            ipchains -X int-fwd
            ipchains -F ext-in
            ipchains -X ext-in
            ipchains -F ext-out
            ipchains -X ext-out
            ipchains -F ext-fwd
            ipchains -X ext-fwd
            ipchains -F dmz-in
            ipchains -X dmz-in
            ipchains -F dmz-out
            ipchains -X dmz-out
            ipchains -F dmz-fwd
            ipchains -X dmz-fwd
            rm -f /var/lock/subsys/firewall
            ipchains -F icmp-acc
            ipchains -X icmp-acc
        fi
}

if [ ! -f /etc/sysconfig/network ]; then
    exit 0
fi

. /etc/sysconfig/network

[ -f /sbin/ipchains ] || exit 0

# See how we were called.
case "$1" in
    start)
        echo -n "Setting firewall: "

        # Flush and set default policy of DENY for in, out and
        # forwarded packets. We are enforcing a restrictive policy under
        # which only that which is EXPLICITLY permitted is allowed.
        ipchains -F input
        ipchains -P input DENY
        ipchains -F output
        ipchains -P output DENY
        ipchains -F forward
        ipchains -P forward DENY
        load_modules
        clear_all_chains

        # *************************************************************
        # Define Packet Handling Chains
        # *************************************************************

        # =============================================================
        # icmp-acc: ICMP traffic handler
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N icmp-acc
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type echo-request -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type echo-reply -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type destination-unreachable -j
ACCEPT
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type source-quench -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type time-exceeded -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type parameter-problem -j ACCEPT

        # Silently drop multicast icmp traffic
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -d 224.0.0.0/8 -j DENY
        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A icmp-acc -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # external interface input
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N ext-in

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # General traffic
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Accept inbound on unprivileged ports
         ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p tcp -d $EXTERN_IP
$UNPRIVPORTS -j ACCEPT
         ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p udp -d $EXTERN_IP
$UNPRIVPORTS -j ACCEPT
        # ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p tcp -d $EXTERN_IP --dport
61000:65096 -j ACCEPT
        # ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p udp -d $EXTERN_IP --dport
61000:65096 -j ACCEPT

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Special handling (Friends & Family)
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p tcp -s <trusted net> -d
$EXTERN_IP -j ACCEPT

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Public-accessable services
        # SSH should go here!
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Accept limited inbound traffic on external interface
        # ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p tcp -d $EXTERN_IP <port> -j
ACCEPT

        # Redirect selected services to DMZ server
        # http (www)
        ipmasqadm portfw -a -P tcp -L 24.1.193.48 80 -R 192.168.10.10 80
        # smtp (mail)
        ipmasqadm portfw -a -P tcp -L 24.1.193.48 25 -R 192.168.10.10 25

        # ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p icmp -j icmp-acc

        # Allow DHCP server responses. Only required if we use DHCP to
        # intialize our WAN interface (i.e. cable modem connection)
        # ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p udp -d $EXTERN_IP --dport
bootpc -j ACCEPT
        # ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -p tcp -d $EXTERN_IP --dport
bootpc -j ACCEPT

        # Hand icmp traffic off to appropriate chain
        ipchains -A ext-in -p icmp -j icmp-acc

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Silently dump broadcasts and other traffic not addressed to
        # us. This keeps misconfigured neighbors from cluttering up our
        # system log.
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -d ! $EXTERN_IP -j DENY

        # Silently dump multicast traffic
        ipchains -A ext-in -i $EXTERN_IF -d 224.0.0.0/8 -j DENY

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A ext-in -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # external interface output
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N ext-out
        # Accept outbound traffic on external (WAN) interface
        ipchains -A ext-out -i $EXTERN_IF -s $EXTERN_IP -d $ANYWHERE -j ACCE
PT
        # ipchains -A ext-out -i $EXTERN_IF -j ACCEPT

        # Allow DHCP server requests. Only required if we use DHCP to
        # intialize our WAN interface (i.e. cable modem connection)
        ipchains -A ext-out -i $EXTERN_IF -p udp --dport bootpc -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A ext-out -i $EXTERN_IF -p tcp --dport bootpc -j ACCEPT

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A ext-out -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # external interface forwarded
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N ext-fwd
        # Forward (masq) traffic routed via external interface
        ipchains -A ext-fwd -i $EXTERN_IF -s $INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -d !
$DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -j MASQ
        ipchains -A ext-fwd -i $EXTERN_IF -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -d !
$INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j MASQ
        # Required for internal routing
        # ipchains -A ext-fwd -i $EXTERN_IF -j ACCEPT

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A ext-fwd -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # internal interface input
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N int-in

        # Accept inbound traffic from LAN on LAN interface
        ipchains -A int-in -i $INTERN_IF -s $INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j
ACCEPT

        # Allow DHCP queries from LAN
        ipchains -A int-in -i $INTERN_IF -p tcp --source-port
bootpc --destination-port bootps -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A int-in -i $INTERN_IF -p udp --source-port
bootpc --destination-port bootps -j ACCEPT

        # Hand icmp traffic off to appropriate chain
        ipchains -A int-in -p icmp -j icmp-acc

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A int-in -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # internal interface output
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N int-out

        # Accept outbound traffic to LAN on LAN interface
        ipchains -A int-out -i $INTERN_IF -d $INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j
ACCEPT

        # Accept inbound traffic from LAN on LAN interface
        ipchains -A int-out -i $INTERN_IF -s $INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j
ACCEPT

        # Allow DHCP responses to LAN
        ipchains -A int-out -i $INTERN_IF -p tcp --source-port
bootps --destination-port bootpc -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A int-out -i $INTERN_IF -p udp --source-port
bootps --destination-port bootpc -j ACCEPT

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A int-out -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # internal interface forward
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N int-fwd

        # Forward (route) local traffic
        ipchains -A int-fwd -d $INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j ACCEPT

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A int-fwd -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # DMZ interface input
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N dmz-in

        # Accept restricted inbound traffic from DMZ on DMZ interface
        # These handled DNS on firewall.
        # ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p udp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK --dport
domain -j ACCEPT
        # ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p tcp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK --dport
domain -j ACCEPT
         # Accept Windows networking traffic
         # ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p tcp -s
$DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK --dport 137:139 -j ACCEPT
         # ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p udp -s
$DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK --dport 137:139 -j ACCEPT

        # Allow non-syn (established) outbound connections from DMZ network
        ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p tcp ! -y -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -j
ACCEPT
        # ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -j ACCEPT

         # Allow ftp connections from external locations
        ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p tcp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK
ftp-data -j ACCEPT
         # Allow outbound udp traffic to internal network
        ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p udp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -d
$INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j ACCEPT

        # Handle ICMP from DMZ
         # ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p icmp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -d
$INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j ACCEPT
        # Disallow ICMP to DMZ interface
         ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p icmp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -d
$DMZ_IP -l -j DENY
         # Disallow ICMP to our internal network
         ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -p icmp -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -d
$INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -l -j DENY
        # Hand icmp traffic off to appropriate chain
        ipchains -A dmz-in -p icmp -j icmp-acc

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Silently dump broadcasts and other traffic not addressed to
        # us. This keeps misconfigured neighbors from cluttering up our
        # system log.
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        ipchains -A dmz-in -i $DMZ_IF -d ! $DMZ_IP -j DENY

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A dmz-in -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # DMZ interface output
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N dmz-out

        # Accept outbound traffic to DMZ on DMZ interface
        ipchains -A dmz-out -i $DMZ_IF -d $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -j ACCEPT

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A dmz-out -l -j DENY

        # =============================================================
        # DMZ interface forward
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -N dmz-fwd

        # Forward (route) local traffic
        ipchains -A dmz-fwd -i $DMZ_IF -d $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -j ACCEPT

        # Verbosely log remaining traffic for debugging purposes
        ipchains -A dmz-fwd -l -j DENY

        # *************************************************************
        # Main packet processing chain
        # *************************************************************

        # =============================================================
        # loopback interface
        # =============================================================
        ipchains -A input -i lo -s $ANYWHERE -d $ANYWHERE -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A output -i lo -s $ANYWHERE -d $ANYWHERE -j ACCEPT
        ipchains -A forward -i lo -s $ANYWHERE -d $ANYWHERE -j ACCEPT

        # =============================================================
        # Direct traffic through chains based on interface
        # =============================================================
         ipchains -A input -i $EXTERN_IF -j ext-in
         ipchains -A output -i $EXTERN_IF -j ext-out
        ipchains -A forward -i $EXTERN_IF -j ext-fwd
         ipchains -A input -i $INTERN_IF -j int-in
         ipchains -A output -i $INTERN_IF -j int-out
        ipchains -A forward -i $INTERN_IF -j int-fwd
         ipchains -A input -i $DMZ_IF -j dmz-in
         ipchains -A output -i $DMZ_IF -j dmz-out
        ipchains -A forward -i $DMZ_IF -j dmz-fwd

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Verbosely log remaining TCP, UDP and ICMP for debugging
        # purposes, silently dump all others using default policy
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        ipchains -A input -l -j DENY
        ipchains -A output -l -j DENY
        ipchains -A forward -l -j DENY

        touch /var/lock/subsys/firewall
        echo "done"
        ;;

    stop)
        echo -n "Stopping firewall (secure): "
        # =============================================================
        # stop: Shut down and enter SECURE mode. Stops all forwarding
        #       thru gateway.
        # =============================================================
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Flush and set default policy of deny for in, out and
        # forwarded packets.
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        ipchains -F input
        ipchains -P input DENY
        ipchains -F output
        ipchains -P output DENY
        ipchains -F forward
        ipchains -P forward DENY
# DEBUG: Will receive error messages if in 'loose' mode,
#        chains don't exist!
        unload_modules
        clear_all_chains

        echo "done"
        ;;

    loose)
        echo -n "Starting gateway (insecure): "
        # =============================================================
        # clear: Stop all packet filtering and enter INSECURE mode.
        #        Allow all traffic thru gateway.
        # =============================================================

        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        # Flush and set default policy of ACCEPT for in, out and
        # forwarded packets.
        # -------------------------------------------------------------
        ipchains -F input
        ipchains -P input ACCEPT
        ipchains -F output
        ipchains -P output ACCEPT
        ipchains -F forward
        ipchains -P forward ACCEPT
        load_modules
        clear_all_chains

        ipchains -A forward -i $EXTERN_IF -s $INTERN_NET/$INTERN_MASK -j
MASQ
        ipchains -A forward -i $EXTERN_IF -s $DMZ_NET/$DMZ_MASK -j MASQ

        touch /var/lock/subsys/firewall
        echo "done"
        ;;

  *)
        echo "Usage: firewall {start|stop|loose}"
        exit 1
esac

exit 0


This actually worked quite well, but