List Use - Replying to Individual Email reappears in the PLUG List? Let's take OT private?

[Dan Lund]

I dont know, according to Lisa's email it sounds like even with
removing plug-discuss at lists.plug.phoenix.az.us (stops for a second to
rest fingers... lol) it still went to the list.
I understand what you meant though, and you're right.  If it did
happen with the reply-to being only the person, that perplexes me too
since nothing is ever included in BCC or CC for me when replying in
any way to plug.

Thanks,
Dan Lund


On Sat, Jun 28, 2008 at 11:07 PM, Alan Dayley <alandd at consultpros.com> wrote:
> Tis a debate found all over the internet: Do we set the email list
> reply-to the list or to the originator?
>
> Our last significant discussion of the issue was in Nov, 2005:
> http://lists.plug.phoenix.az.us/lurker/thread/20051117.225149.8564d356.en.html#20051117.225149.8564d356
>
> Our list is set to reply to the whole list to encourage more "on list"
> discussion.  If we set it the other way, technically the "right" way,
> there will be complaints from the other side.  There is no "win-win"
> without a change to the list server software to allow each user to set
> it the way they want.
>
> If you and others want to discuss it, keep it civil and that's fine with
> me.  I don't think it will end with all sides happy because there is no
> compromise position without one or the other needing to accommodate the
> other way.
>
> Thanks for trying to keep the list on topic.
>
> Alan