Speeding up X11 forwarding

Matt Graham danceswithcrows at usa.net
Tue Dec 18 09:34:04 MST 2007


After a long battle with technology, der.hans wrote:
> Am 18. Dec, 2007 schwätzte Bryan O'Neal so:
> >> Bryan O'Neal wrote:
> >>> pipes at one end, and fairly good pipes at the other end, using X11
> >>> aps like firefox is downright painful.

AFAICT, the slowdowns affect GTK+ apps much more than Qt apps.  I know that 
the last time I tested running apps over ssh -X on a slow pipe, firefox was 
unusable while konqueror worked reasonably well.  Modern application/widget 
programmers are just not optimizing stuff for non-local connections, since so 
few people do that these days.

> > Standard VNC gives me a blank xterm more often then a useful desktop.

If you meant "vncserver", then that's exactly what it's supposed to do.  This 
is by design, as providing a new virtual Display is easier than 
screen-scraping an existing Display and using XTest to manipulate it.  Since 
people like to manipulate existing Displays and the X clients on them, they 
invented x11vnc (and xmove, but xmove, while a neat idea, is too @#$%^ing 
slow.)

> > In addition I can not get NX working in under three to four hours

Wow.  It's been a while since I messed with NX, but something is wrong here.  
x11vnc on Fedora 7 (no x11vnc RPM there, oddly enough) required installing 
all the X development packages, then compiling from the tarball.  About 30 
minutes IIRC.

> > How easy (read fast) is FoxyProxy to set up?
> A few minutes. Figuring it out the first time might take a while,
> depending on your familiarity with globbing or regular expressions.
> Simple setups on a local browser could easily take less than a minute to
> setup again.

Interesting.  I'll have to check out that extension later.

> > But you are correct -C should be there.
> C, it's not just for fighting colds :).

I don't think -C helped that much when I tried it, but I didn't add -c 
blowfish .

-- 
   I will rule you all with my iron fist.  YOU!  Obey the fist!
   --Invader Zim
There is no Darkness in Eternity/But only Light too dim for us to see


More information about the PLUG-discuss mailing list